Almost everything that keeps your sugar dating life separate from the rest of your life comes down to decisions you make yourself, and most of them are made in the first week. Private Sugar Club has a large and active member base, so a lot of people can read your profile before you have chosen to talk to any of them.
Sugar dating does ask for openness eventually. It does not ask for all of it at once.
What Goes in a Sugar Dating Profile
Your username reaches a reader before your bio does. If the handle you choose here matches one you use on a photo app or a gaming account, anyone curious enough to type it into a search engine has a thread back into your everyday life. Choose something you have never used anywhere else, and leave your initials out. A username that means nothing to anyone but you is doing its job.
A bio can be warm and specific without being traceable. Say that you like long dinners and terrible horror movies, or that you cook on Sundays. Those are real things about you, and none of them says where to find you. What stays out is anything a stranger could act on without your help. Your employer's name belongs in that group, and so does the block you live on.
Nothing on a profile has to be complete.
You only need enough for someone to write you a decent opening message, and the rest belongs to conversations that have not happened yet. Private Sugar Club publishes a Privacy Policy, and it is worth reading before you fill anything in.
Keeping Your Dating Life Separate From Everything Else
Set up an email address for this and nothing else. The address you use for work and shopping carries your full name in the sender field and ties your accounts together. A fresh address breaks that link. Do the same with the name you give people. A first name that is not the one on your mail will carry you through the early conversations, and handing over the real one later stays a step you choose. There is nothing awkward about saying you go by something else for now.
Your phone number belongs near the end of the sequence. A number attached to a chat app usually carries a display name and a picture with it, so passing it along shares more than a way to reach you.
Separation is easy to loosen later and impossible to add after the fact.
Telling someone your real first name in month two takes one sentence, and there is no way to take it back afterward.
Can Someone Find Your Photos Somewhere Else Online?
Yes, if those photos are somewhere else online already. A search engine will take a picture as its query and look for copies of it, so anyone holding your profile photo can ask where else that image appears. It takes no skill and no special tools.
So take pictures for this profile and use them nowhere else. If a photo also appears on a public account under your own name, a reverse image search connects the two in one step. Then look at what else is in the frame. A work lanyard, a piece of mail on the counter or the view from your window will place you faster than a caption could. Crop tight, or shoot against a wall.
Most people do not notice any of this until they look back through pictures they already chose. Go through yours now. Anything you would not hand to a colleague is worth replacing.
Small Details That Identify You Faster Than a Name
A full name on its own often finds nothing. A job title and a part of town together will find a person in a few clicks, and a dog's name or a high school finishes the job.
These are the specifics worth rationing.
- where you work, and what you do if the field is a small one
- the part of town you live in, and the route you walk every morning
- the gym, the coffee place or the bar you are in most weeks
- your high school or college
- a pet's name, a birthday, a childhood street
That last group has a second life as the answer to a security question, so it is worth keeping out of a first conversation. You do not have to be cagey about everything. Rationing four or five specifics leaves plenty to talk about.
How to Pace What You Share
In the first week, a first name and a rough part of town will carry a conversation a long way. Saying that you work in healthcare tells someone real things about your days without naming a building. Tastes and opinions give away nothing, and they are the interesting part anyway.
Later comes the rest. Your employer and your street can wait until you have met someone a few times and have some sense of them. Your full name and your other accounts can wait longer than that. None of it has a deadline.
Holding something back only reads badly when nothing comes with it. Try answering the spirit of the question and naming a horizon. "I keep work out of this for now, and I will tell you about it once we have met a few times" does that in one line.
Pacing runs in both directions, and someone who answers your early questions in general terms is doing what you are doing.
How Do You Bring Up Discretion?
Say it out loud in the first week, while there is nothing yet to protect.
Two people can both call themselves discreet and mean different things by it, so ask what it covers for them. Start with who gets to know about this and how much they are told, then what either of you posts on social media. Photographs of the two of you are their own conversation, since a picture can move around without either of you sending it.
Raising it early has a second use. How someone answers that question tells you a good deal about how carefully your name will be treated later. If the answer is casual, that is worth knowing in week one.
Discretion also has to be kept by you. Your own group chat is as much a route out as anyone else's. So is a photo posted from the door of a restaurant.
When Someone Pushes for Personal Details
Pressure for personal information is a behavior, and you can answer the behavior without deciding anything about the person behind it. Say no once and say it in a sentence, with no apology attached. "I am not sharing that yet" is a complete answer.
If the request comes back in different words, you have learned how your limits will be handled later. Repeat your answer and add nothing to it.
Ending a conversation is always available and needs no explanation. Close the window on someone who keeps asking, and treat that as the end of it.
Dr. Emily May
Dr. Emily May is an AASECT-certified sex therapist and writer at Private Sugar Club. Her work has been featured in Men's Health, Lifehacker, Metro, The i Paper, Playboy, and Ladbible.
Read full bio →As featured in
